Market Common Olive Shoppe
Shop owner Darya Suddreth, (right) with longtime friend and compatriot in olive oil love, Dawn Yarborough (left) outside the shop on Howard Avenue.

The Olive Shoppe…Tasters Welcome

Where Shopping is Pure Epicurean Pleasure

Right in the heart of the Soho district of the Market Common is a lovely store featuring epicurean delights from the Mediterranean and beyond— The Olive Shoppe… Tasters Welcome.

Darya Suddreth, who grew up in Surfside Beach, began the business with her husband, John, five years ago.

“When my daughter was two,” she tells me, “she was diagnosed with juvenile diabetes. In order to get her to eat healthier, we started using a lot of olive oil and balsamic vinegar on her foods. And it was amazing the types of foods she began to eat.”

It sparked a love and fascination with olive oil and balsamic vinegar for the Suddreth family, which gradually evolved into a total life makeover.

“My husband and I wanted to be entrepreneurs— we were looking for opportunities,” says Darya. “He wanted to leave Charlotte, where we were living at the time, and move back to the beach. This is where we met; he wanted to raise our children here.

“John had been to an olive oil shop in California and thought it was a great thing to do in Myrtle Beach. When the opportunity arose for us to move back, we did. And it’s probably the best move we ever made.”

The pair opened their first store at Barefoot Landing, July 1, 2011. They opened a second location at the Cotton Exchange in Wilmington, N.C. in 2012. And in May 2015, they opened their location in the Market Common.

Different types of olive oils; tasting bar
The bar at The Olive Shoppe may be the healthiest one you'll ever visit. (Photo Meganpixels Parker)

Lucky for us who visit or live here.

Stepping into The Olive Shoppe, I’m transported to a different place, where olive oils and balsamic vinegars from around the world sit side by side, emanating their unique multicultural self-expression in the form of heavenly taste.

The shop sells traditional extra virgin olive oils from Argentina, Chile, Greece, Italy, Spain, Tunisia, and Turkey. Darya and John are currently looking into adding oils from Jordan and Mexico. They also carry hand-stuffed olives, olive spreads, and olives and brine to make special martinis.

“At The Olive Shoppe, we want our customers to have a tasting experience that will wow the senses,” Darya says. 

I try the jalapeño infused olive oil which she pairs with peach white balsamic vinegar, and assure her she’s on track with her mission.

“We have a full service tasting bar, where our customers have the opportunity to sit down, and we are like bartenders with olive oil and balsamic vinegars,” she says. “I always say,” she adds with a laugh, ‘It’s the healthiest bar you’ll ever belly up to!’”

Before the two began their venture, they researched a lot of olive oil growers and companies— something they continue to do to this day.

“We are constantly looking for new growers and suppliers, and we hand pick every one we work with, not just for their taste, but also for their company principles and growing practices,” Darya says. “Every one that we select is very high quality.”

For their flavor-infused olive oils, they selected oils exclusively from Spain, with strongly infused flavors— Darya’s preference.

Olive oils and balsamic vinegars from around the world line the walls at The Olive Shoppe. (Photo Meganpixels Parker)

“I found that the majority of flavored olive oils I tried were not very prominent with that flavor, or hard to discern from the strong flavor of the oil,” Darya explains. “I like that Spanish olive oil is lighter in taste, and therefore the flavors don’t compete with one another.”

All of their balsamic vinegars are imported from Modena, Italy. They are rich and thick, like a glaze, the way Italians have been making them for centuries. The flavors of these balsamics can’t begin to compare to what you can find in the grocery store.

As I bite into a garlic and herb cheese-stuffed olive (pure heaven) handmade by a small California farmer, Darya continues to tell me about the many uses of flavored olive oils and balsamics beyond salad dressing.

Put strawberry balsamic over vanilla ice cream; cracked black pepper olive oil to marinate and tenderize meat; Meyer lemon olive oil can be added to brownie mixes; the pineapple white balsamic also goes divinely with the jalapeño oil over fish.

The options and potential seem endless, and with approximately 50-60 varieties of flavored oils and balsamics, and a little creative genius thrown in the mix, they just might be.

Dawn Yarborough, a longtime friend and customer who now works at the shop says, “Once you start cooking with olive oils and balsamics, you have no idea how creative you are. You just amaze yourself. You lose all fear in the kitchen. And,” she adds with a sly smile, “your friends think you’re a chef. So come on in and taste with us!”

The Olive Shoppe

Open M-Sa 10am-6pm 

Melissa LaScaleia

+ posts

The Insider's Literary Editor and co-writer with Charlie, is a Boston-born ballet dancer and Harvard University graduate with a degree in art history and architecture. Her passion lies in exploring international cultures, indulging in fine dining, and savoring the beauty of both human and natural creations. For Melissa, a superb meal is like consuming a painting, reflecting the chef's creativity, focus, confidence, passion, and love. Each bite serves as a reminder of life's impermanence, prompting her to appreciate the cyclical nature of life and death in the world. Melissa finds nourishment for her soul in wild, untouched places and various forms of beauty, expressing deep gratitude for the natural wonders and those who strive to preserve them on our planet.

Join our Mailing List

Be the first to know about the best eats, shops, sights and escapes of Myrtle Beach